Skip to content

Measurement

Based on Sean Carroll's "Quantum and Fields"

Key Concepts

1. Quantum Measurement

In quantum mechanics, measurement differs significantly from classical systems.

  • Observables are represented by operators; the eigenvalues of these operators correspond to possible measurement outcomes.
  • Born Rule for measuring an eigenvalue \( a_i \):

$$ P(a_i) = \bigl|\langle \psi \mid a_i\rangle \bigr|^2 $$

Upon measurement, the wavefunction \(\psi\) collapses to the corresponding eigenstate \(\lvert a_i\rangle\).

2. Wavefunction Collapse and Quantum Indeterminism

  • Quantum Indeterminism: Outcomes are probabilistic rather than deterministic.
  • The wavefunction \(\psi\) encodes probabilities for all possible measurement results.
  • A measurement collapses \(\psi\) to the observed eigenstate.

3. Wave-Particle Duality and the Double-Slit Experiment

  • Wave-Particle Duality: Particles (e.g., electrons, photons) exhibit both wave-like and particle-like properties.
  • Double-Slit Experiment:
  • Without observation: Particles pass through both slits like waves, creating an interference pattern.
  • With observation: Particles act like discrete entities, and the interference pattern vanishes.

Implications:
- Demonstrates quantum superposition and indeterminism.
- Highlights how measurement alters system behavior.

4. The Reality Problem

Key Question: Does the wavefunction represent physical reality or a mere tool for probability?

  • Copenhagen Interpretation: Wavefunction collapses upon measurement.
  • Many-Worlds Interpretation: No collapse; all outcomes occur in parallel branches.

5. Hilbert Space

  • Hilbert space provides the mathematical framework for quantum states, with each state represented as a vector in this space.
  • Operators (e.g., position, momentum, spin) act on these vectors to predict outcomes.

Key Properties:
- Potentially infinite-dimensional.
- Inner product \(\langle \psi_1 \mid \psi_2\rangle\) defines probabilities and orthogonality.

Differences from Classical Space-Time:
- Nature: Classical space-time describes physical geometry; Hilbert space is an abstract state space.
- Dimensionality: Space-time has 3+1 dimensions; Hilbert space can be infinite-dimensional.
- Purpose: Space-time locates objects physically; Hilbert space underpins quantum predictions.
- Structure: Hilbert space is linear (enabling superposition), whereas space-time is not necessarily linear in that sense.

6. Qubits

A qubit is the quantum analog of a classical bit:

\[ |\psi\rangle = \alpha|0\rangle + \beta|1\rangle \quad\text{with}\quad |\alpha|^2 + |\beta|^2 = 1. \]
  • Measurement collapses the qubit to \(\lvert 0\rangle\) or \(\lvert 1\rangle\) with probabilities \(|\alpha|^2\) and \(|\beta|^2\).

7. Operators and Observables

  • Operators correspond to measurable quantities.
  • Commutation Relations:

$$ [\hat{A}, \hat{B}] = \hat{A}\hat{B} - \hat{B}\hat{A}. $$

  • If \([\hat{A}, \hat{B}] = 0\), they are compatible (can be measured simultaneously).
  • If \([\hat{A}, \hat{B}] \neq 0\), they are incompatible.

8. Uncertainty Principle

The Heisenberg Uncertainty Principle limits simultaneous knowledge of certain pairs of observables (e.g., position \(x\) and momentum \(p\)).

\[ \Delta x \,\Delta p \,\ge \,\frac{\hbar}{2} \]
  • \(\Delta x\): Uncertainty in position
  • \(\Delta p\): Uncertainty in momentum

Explanation:
- Arises from the wave nature of quantum systems (Fourier transform relationship).
- Localizing a wavefunction in position space broadens it in momentum space, and vice versa.
- For an illustrative video, see 3Blue1Brown’s explanation.

9. Momentum and Measurement

  • Momentum is represented by the operator:

$$ \hat{p} = -\,i\hbar \,\frac{\partial}{\partial x}. $$

  • Measuring momentum collapses the wavefunction into a momentum eigenstate.

Important Examples

Spin Measurement
- Measuring spin along any axis collapses the state to \(|+\rangle\) or \(|-\rangle\).
- Spin measurements along different axes (e.g., \(x, y, z\)) are incompatible.

Double-Slit Experiment
- Demonstrates quantum superposition and the significance of measurement.

Position and Momentum
- Conjugate variables governed by \(\Delta x \,\Delta p \,\ge \,\hbar/2\).

Takeaways

  1. Measurement is central to quantum mechanics, introducing probabilities and wavefunction collapse.
  2. Observables are encoded as operators, whose eigenvalues/eigenstates determine outcomes.
  3. The uncertainty principle and wave-particle duality emphasize the unique nature of quantum systems.
  4. The double-slit experiment highlights indeterminism and the measurement problem.
  5. Hilbert space provides the core mathematical structure of quantum mechanics.

Resources

  1. Quanta and Fields by Sean Carroll
  2. 3Blue1Brown's video on the uncertainty principle

← Wave Function | Entanglement →